Everyone is talking about Paula Abdul after Idol Tuesday night. She flubbed up and critiqued both songs for David Cook after he had done only one song. Well, here’s the thing, Simon told in an interview that they watch the final rehearsal to listen to the songs and how they sing the songs. The reasoning stated was that with the crowd during the live show, it’s nearly impossible to hear whether they know their song, their tone while singing the song, whether it hits the marks where it should, vocally. They write down notes during that, then during the live show, they judge the actual performance, how they connect with the audience, how they are on stage, etc.
All of this makes sense to me, really. Plus, it also explains why sometimes we wonder if they’re hearing a different song. For instance, they seem to love David Archuletta’s songs, but to me, he’s not that good. They hear the crowd-less performance that he can really shine on, then when he hits the live stage, he chokes a bit, but they don’t hear it with the crowd noise. I don’t see the big deal, honestly.
I do think they need to stop making excuses and tell the truth, however. Trying to cover the flub up doesn’t help them any. Anyway. That’s my thoughts on Tuesday night’s controversy. My thoughts on the final 4…
Jason Castro - I really like his voice, I like his style. BUT he needs to step outside his comfort zone more, quit sitting on the stool, show some energy, do something upbeat, do something FUN. Show some versatility. Period.
David Archuletta - I liked him in the beginning, he was better early on, but now? I’m not so much of a fan. He also doesn’t step outside of his box either. He really pissed me off when he (imo) destroyed Think Of Me. While I appreciate his trying to make the song his own, it’s not a pop song, it is not a song that you do that to. He’s really lucky he has a following that kept him safe.
Syesha Mercado - I am not surprised she is still there, she fits the mold for AI winners. She’s the diva of the season, so she managed to get far. I don’t like her, she tries too hard to be Whitney, Mariah, Aretha, etc. That’s my thoughts on her.
David Cook - Now, this is someone who should win. He is strong week after week. He has a strong voice, a strong style, he will have a great career in the end. If he doesn’t win, perhaps it’s better for him. Male winners haven’t had the best track record. So yeah.
So that’s my thoughts.. what about you?